Staff Reports
A recent call from French politician Raphaël Glucksmann to return the Statue of Liberty to France has ignited a heated debate, though many see it as more symbolic than serious. Glucksmann, a member of the European Parliament and co-leader of the Place Publique party, argued that the United States no longer embodies the values that inspired France to gift the statue in 1886. His remarks, delivered during a political rally, criticized America’s current policies under President Donald Trump, particularly regarding scientific freedom and international diplomacy. The White House swiftly dismissed the suggestion, with Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt delivering a pointed rebuke.
Leavitt’s response underscored America’s historical role in liberating France during World War II, reminding Glucksmann that “it is only because of the United States that the French are not speaking German right now.” Her comments reflect a broader frustration with what many conservatives see as European ingratitude toward America’s sacrifices for global freedom. The Statue of Liberty, a gift symbolizing friendship and shared democratic ideals, is not just an artifact but a testament to the enduring bond between two nations. Calls to return it are seen as both impractical and dismissive of this history.
Glucksmann’s critique highlights growing tensions between Europe and the United States over policy differences. He accused America of aligning with “tyrants” and abandoning its commitment to liberty, referencing Trump’s controversial decisions on Ukraine and domestic scientific research. However, conservatives argue that such accusations ignore the complexities of modern governance and America’s continued leadership in defending Western values. From supporting Ukraine against Russian aggression to maintaining global security through NATO, they contend that America remains a pillar of freedom.
The demand to return Lady Liberty also raises questions about Europe’s commitment to liberty. While Glucksmann criticizes American policies, France itself faces challenges with rising authoritarianism within its borders and across Europe. Conservatives argue that instead of pointing fingers at America, European leaders should focus on addressing their struggles with free speech, immigration, and national sovereignty. The Statue of Liberty stands as a reminder of shared ideals, but those ideals require effort from all parties involved—not just criticism from afar.
Ultimately, calls like Glucksmann’s are viewed as political grandstanding rather than genuine proposals. The Statue of Liberty is not merely a gift; it is U.S. property and an enduring symbol of American resilience and freedom. While international critics may question America’s direction, conservatives maintain that the country continues to uphold its founding principles in ways that adapt to modern challenges. If anything, this episode serves as a reminder that gratitude for past alliances should guide future cooperation—not divisive rhetoric aimed at rewriting history.
