The big news out of Dane County is simple and sharp: Dane County District Attorney Ismael R. Ozanne has announced he will not file criminal charges against the Madison police officers involved in the July officer‑involved shooting that killed Corey Ruiz. That decision follows a statewide DCI investigation and a thick file of video, reports, and other evidence. For anyone expecting a headline trial, today was a reality check.
DA Ozanne’s ruling: why there are no charges
Ozanne reviewed the Wisconsin DOJ Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) record and concluded the facts do not support criminal liability. The DA says officers attempted less‑lethal options, that the suspect produced a knife, resisted and did not appear stopped by Tasers, and that an officer reasonably feared deadly force was imminent. Under Wisconsin law, deadly force is lawful when an officer faces a genuine threat of death or serious injury. That legal standard matters, and Ozanne says the evidence meets it — which is why he declined to charge the officer who fired.
What the evidence shows about the encounter
State investigators identified the officer who fired as Madison Police Officer Kiel Baitinger‑Peterson. Video released and summarized by investigators shows three shots fired at close range during a struggle. Madison officers do not wear body cameras, so squad video isn’t available; bystander and surveillance footage have driven public view of the scene. The DCI led the probe as state law requires for officer‑involved deaths. The officers remain on paid administrative leave while the department completes its internal review and the family pursues civil remedies.
Public reaction, protests, and the next steps
Predictably, the decision split opinion. Civil rights lawyer Ben Crump blasted the ruling and said the videos show no justification. Local officials, including Governor‑elect David Crowley, urged calm and peaceful protest. The police union and many law‑and‑order voices said the DA’s decision matched the facts and existing legal standards. Expect civil lawsuits, administrative complaints, and more political theater — and remember that unverified outrage on social media is not the same thing as a court case.
Here’s the blunt take: the criminal process has spoken on this one, for now. That doesn’t erase the loss of life or the hard questions about policing in Madison — like whether body cameras should be mandatory or whether training and tactics need reform. Conservatives can and should defend lawful officers who face real danger. But we can also demand better transparency and policies so tragedies like the Ruiz case are less likely to happen. If people want accountability, use the right tools: policy change, civil courts, and local elections — not mob outrage and cheap headlines.

