Senator‑elect Abdul El‑Sayed told NPR he “will likely swear on the Qur’an” when he takes the oath of office. Governor Ron DeSantis answered with a social‑media history lesson, quoting a Founding‑Era diplomatic report about the Tripoli ambassador and reminding Americans that Jefferson’s copy of the Qur’an was a study aid in a time when the young Republic fought the Barbary pirates. This exchange puts a spotlight on symbolism, constitutional practice, and who gets to claim the Founders’ legacy.
What Senator‑elect El‑Sayed actually said
On NPR’s Newsmakers program, Senator‑elect Abdul El‑Sayed said he “will likely swear on the Qur’an,” and he mentioned Thomas Jefferson’s historic copy as well as an old Qur’an held by the University of Michigan as possible choices. He also referenced the 2007 photo‑op when then‑Congressman Keith Ellison used Jefferson’s Qur’an in a ceremonial moment. That’s honest and simple: he said what he plans to do, and he pointed to precedent for ceremonial use of Jefferson’s copy.
Why Governor DeSantis pushed back with Jefferson and the Barbary pirates
Governor Ron DeSantis reposted an 18th‑century diplomatic passage that reports a Tripoli ambassador’s claim about warfare being grounded in the laws of the prophet as written in the Qur’an. DeSantis used that snippet to argue Jefferson studied the book as a document about a hostile power — and then noted Jefferson later fought the Barbary pirates as president. The governor’s point is clear: Jefferson’s ownership of a Qur’an does not mean the Founders viewed Islam as a friendly political model. It’s a sharp rebuttal to anyone trying to use Jefferson as a cultural endorsement.
Constitutional facts and ceremonial precedent
Let’s be plain: the Constitution requires an oath or an affirmation, not a specific Bible. Officials have sworn on Bibles, constitutions, or nothing at all. Ceremonially, Jefferson’s Qur’an has been used before. But there’s a difference between an allowed ceremonial choice and what symbolically binds an elected official to the American people. Americans have a right to ask whether an oath choice is merely private faith or an outward signal about loyalties and values. That question matters in a time when some foreign and ideological actors celebrated El‑Sayed’s win as a model for advancing an agenda from inside American institutions.
Bottom line — questions voters deserve answered
This is more than a media soundbite. El‑Sayed’s comment and DeSantis’s historical reply force a public conversation about symbolism, loyalty, and the Founders’ record. History is messy; Jefferson read widely and fought when he had to. If Senator‑elect El‑Sayed intends to use the Qur’an as his oath object, he should explain plainly to voters what that choice means for his oath to uphold the Constitution. And if Governor DeSantis wants to keep reminding people that America’s founders studied many books — including ones belonging to rivals — that’s fair too. Americans should expect clarity, not posture, from their new leaders.

