The housing recovery just hit a speed bump — a big one. New data from the National Association of REALTORS® shows existing‑home sales fell to their weakest pace in more than a decade. Meanwhile, HUD quietly trimmed some FHA rules earlier in the year and called it a win. It isn’t.
October sales plunged — the numbers are ugly
The National Association of REALTORS® reported existing‑home sales fell to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.75 million in October. That is a 5.5% drop from September and the weakest pace since 2010. NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun pointed squarely at mortgage rates and affordability as the main reasons buyers are dropping out of the market.
HUD’s appraisal changes are a drop in the bucket
This year HUD loosened FHA appraisal‑review rules and said it would save lenders roughly $425 per review and about $3.3 million industrywide. HUD Secretary Scott Turner called the move a cut of “unnecessary regulation.” Fine — but a few million in lender savings won’t lower mortgage payments the way families need. The Appraisal Institute warned that making reviews optional raises real questions about oversight and valuation integrity, which is worth noting before declaring victory.
Rates drive payments, not paperwork
Here’s the plain math. Freddie Mac’s 30‑year fixed mortgage has been in the low‑to‑mid 7% range recently — far above last year. That jump adds hundreds of dollars to a typical monthly mortgage payment. One widely cited estimate shows higher rates added roughly $223 a month to the median monthly principal and interest payment with 20% down. HUD’s $425 per review saving doesn’t come close to offsetting that kind of pain for buyers.
Federal policy is the real reason housing can’t recover
If you want to know why rates are high, look past the paperwork. Tariffs have passed costs into prices, energy disruptions and tanker attacks pushed oil higher, and fast‑growing federal borrowing nudges long‑term yields up. Those are the forces that lift mortgage rates, choke affordability, and slow sales. Tightening a few lender rules won’t fix that macro picture.
Bottom line: the NAR data tells the story — the housing recovery has stalled because borrowing costs are too high. HUD’s regulatory cleanup is welcome, but it is a Band‑Aid on a problem caused by bigger policy choices. If Washington wants housing to heal, it should stop adding to inflation and debt and let supply and private capital work. Otherwise, expect more months like this one.

