Staff Reports
The courtroom drama over former Milwaukee County Circuit Court Judge Hannah Dugan just hit another turn. This week U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman denied Dugan’s motion seeking a new trial or a judgment of acquittal, leaving her felony obstruction conviction intact. Sentencing remains adjourned while the defense prepares an appeal.
What the judge decided
Motion to vacate denied — conviction stands
Judge Lynn Adelman issued a written order rejecting the defense’s bid to undo the jury verdict. The court found no reversible error in its prior handling of jury questions and instructions. In short: the jury’s guilty verdict on the obstruction charge survives, and Dugan’s challenge failed to show she was prejudiced by the way the trial was run.
Why the court rejected Dugan’s arguments
Dugan’s team argued several points, but the court saw through them. They relied on a recent appeals court decision that narrowed the reach of the federal obstruction statute, and they argued that judicial immunity should protect a judge from criminal liability for courtroom actions. The judge considered those claims and concluded they did not change the outcome on the record in this case.
What comes next
The defense has signaled it will appeal to the Seventh Circuit. Meanwhile, sentencing is still on hold — the court has not set a new date. An appeal will focus on whether the federal obstruction law covered Dugan’s conduct, whether jury instructions were proper, and whether any form of immunity applies. Until an appellate court weighs in, the conviction remains in the record.
Why this matters
This ruling is a clear reminder that no one is above the law, not even a former judge. The case started after Dugan allegedly interfered with an immigration enforcement action in the courthouse hallway. Victims and law enforcement deserve a system that treats everyone equally and enforces the rules. If judges think they can act as law unto themselves, expect more chaos — and more courtroom fights about whether accountability means anything at all.
