Enough with the theatrics. NPR’s Code Switch ran an episode asking whether “fitness” can be used by fascists, and a University of Michigan professor answered in a careful, academic way. Then a bunch of short clips showed up online and turned that careful answer into a viral meltdown. The result: a lot of finger pointing, hot takes, and people acting like squats are now a political ideology. Spare me.
Clip vs. Context: What Ava Purkiss Actually Said
Professor Ava Purkiss of the University of Michigan, an associate professor of women’s and gender studies and author of a book about Black women and exercise, made a conditional point on Code Switch. She traced historical moments when fitness became a way for states and elites to rank people and warned that using fitness as a proxy to sort people “can be a tool of soft fascism, maybe even actual fascism.” That is a scholarly claim about history and power, not a headline screaming “push‑ups = fascism.”
History Matters — But Hyperbole Doesn’t
Yes, Purkiss’s work looks at how states and elites once tied fitness to citizenship and worth. That history is real and worth studying. But turning that into a broad claim that modern gym culture is racialized or fascist is a leap. Hasan Piker, another guest on the show, pushed back against a blanket reading. You don’t get to ignore nuance and then act surprised when conservatives do the exact same thing back — they take a clip, throttle it, and sell outrage.
Media Playbook: Viral Clips and Who Profits
Here’s the predictable part: short clips hit social media, right‑of‑center outlets fan the flames, and the story becomes “Professor Says Exercise Is Racist.” Some critics even claimed NPR’s transcript left out a word or two to make the clip look worse. People should compare the audio, the full transcript, and the viral clip before shrieking. But nuance rarely pays ad revenue the way outrage does.
Let’s end with common sense. Working out is good for your body, your mind, and often your wallet (less doctor bills). If you want to have a grown‑up conversation about how institutions have used physical fitness in the past to exclude people, fine — that’s what historians do. But turning dumb soundbites into moral panic about treadmills is just another circus act. Read the whole episode, not the five‑second clip, and maybe pick up a dumbbell instead of a pitchfork.

