in

Mamdani Bans Central Park Carriages, TWU Sues Over Medallions

Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch’s Law this week, ending horse-drawn carriage rides in Central Park by June 1, 2028 — and minutes later the Transport Workers Union rushed to federal court to try to stop it. What was billed as an animal‑welfare and safety move has already turned into a property‑rights and pork fight that will play out in court and in city budget rooms for months.

What Romanch’s Law actually does

The law bars new carriage licenses and sets a hard deadline for existing licenses to expire on May 31, 2028. City Hall says it will work on medallion buybacks, job training stipends and horse retirement plans, and that a full transition plan will be released after worker and union talks next spring. That sounds tidy in a press release. But the mayor’s office has not given a dollar figure for buybacks, and drivers and owners say they paid big sums for those medallions and can’t be wiped out on a wink.

Why the Transport Workers Union sued

Minutes after the signing, TWU President John Samuelsen filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan arguing the law is an unconstitutional taking that strips owners of property without guaranteed compensation. The union is also blasting the ban on selling horses to other operators — even out of state — and the limits on where the horses may be placed. This is not just about horses or “tradition”; it’s about whether city politicians can nullify private investments and call it progress.

Politics, pageantry, and a national reaction

Mayor Mamdani signed the bill flanked by allies while former Mayor Bill de Blasio stood by approvingly. President Donald Trump criticized the move as killing “a quintessential New York experience” and said politics drove the decision. For a mayor who promises support for workers, the timeline from law to lawsuit looks like bad theater: a headline for city hall and a costly courtroom fight for taxpayers and former carriage owners.

What to watch next

Keep an eye on the TWU federal complaint and any emergency motion to block the ban — a judge could pause enforcement while the case is decided. Watch how the city plans to value medallions and where the buyback money will come from. The April transition plan should answer hard questions about compensation and retraining; if it doesn’t, this will get messier, faster. New York will cheer its moral victory; those who paid for medallions will be left arguing over dollars and rights. That’s not progress — it’s politics with a court date.

Written by Staff Reports

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fiona the Hippo Dies After Child's Hat Toss — Fix Zoo Safety

Fiona the Hippo Dies After Child’s Hat Toss — Fix Zoo Safety

Newsom Boasts Crime Drop; Critics Say Data Tricks

Newsom Boasts Crime Drop; Critics Say Data Tricks